The complaint
The Beard Club, Inc. v. CF Partnership Holdings LLC, No. 6:26-cv-02443-PGB-CAB, is a 62-page complaint and demand for jury trial, filed October 19, 2026, in the United States District Court for the Middle District of Florida, Orlando Division. The plaintiff is The Beard Club, Inc., a Delaware corporation. The defendants are CF Partnership Holdings LLC, a Florida limited liability company d/b/a Best Beard Stuff, and Daniel Chang d/b/a Lexington Chang, an individual and citizen of the State of Florida. An October 20, 2026 docket entry assigns the case to Judge Paul G. Byron and Magistrate Judge Chauncey A. Bratt and states the case number 6:26-cv-02443-PGB-CAB. The complaint says this is a false advertising and trade dress infringement case under the Lanham Act and related Florida laws. It alleges that the defendants are making willfully false and misleading advertising claims about their beard-growth products and about the plaintiff's beard-growth products, and that they are infringing the plaintiff's trade dress in its website design.
The complaint alleges that the defendants operate the brand Best Beard Stuff and sell beard-growth products, including Beard Growth Kits and the GROW Maximum XXL Growth Accelerator, which the complaint calls GROW XXL. It alleges that they market those products with claims that efficacy has been validated by independent institutions, government-backed science, clinical research, and established media, and that those claims are false and are likely to deceive reasonable consumers of beard-growth products. It alleges that the claims are material because consumers choosing between Best Beard Stuff products and competing products, including The Beard Club's, rely on them. It alleges that the parties compete for the same customers through direct-to-consumer websites and on Amazon, at overlapping price points. It alleges that consumers who bought the defendants' products have contacted The Beard Club for refunds, believing the products were The Beard Club's, and that The Beard Club's customer-acquisition and retention costs have risen and its goodwill is being eroded.
The parties and the registrations
The complaint alleges that The Beard Club's principal place of business is in Westwood, New Jersey, and that it sells beard-growth kits, beard-care products, and grooming tools, including beard growth oil, beard growth vitamins, a vitamin spray, a derma roller, and a trimmer, through thebeardclub.com, Amazon.com, and other retail channels. It alleges that the company was founded in 2015 as a direct-to-consumer business, that it has spent in excess of $80,000,000 advertising and promoting its products, and that it has a customer base of more than 2,000,000 purchasers who have generated over tens of thousands of five-star product reviews. It alleges that The Beard Club promotes its products on Facebook, Instagram, X, YouTube, and TikTok, and through email, subscription marketing, and retail media.
The complaint alleges that CF Partnership Holdings LLC conducts business as Best Beard Stuff, a registered fictitious name, and that the company identifies its principal place of business as Orlando, Florida. It alleges, on information and belief, that Daniel Chang is an individual residing in the State of Florida. It alleges, on information and belief, that Lexington Chang is an alias of Daniel Chang. It alleges, on information and belief, that Daniel Chang is the owner and registrant of the BEST BEARD STUFF trademarks. It alleges that he is the registrant of those trademarks and the listed contact for CF Partnership Holdings LLC and, on information and belief, the operator of a TikTok account that the complaint says has over 10,000 followers and has been used to advertise Best Beard Stuff growth products. It alleges, on information and belief, that he owns and controls the company and personally controls and/or participates in the advertising described in the complaint. It alleges personal jurisdiction over him because he resides in Florida, personally creates and disseminates advertising for the products, and is the registrant of the BEST BEARD STUFF trademarks, and, on information and belief, because he personally directs and controls the company's advertising and business from within Florida. It alleges, on information and belief, that he resides in this District.
The complaint alleges that, long before the conduct at issue, The Beard Club secured federal registration of its core brand assets, including U.S. Trademark Registration No. 6,076,766 for THE BEARD CLUB, registered June 9, 2020. A record of the United States Patent and Trademark Office lists that registration as live on the Principal Register, owned by The Beard Club, Inc., a Delaware corporation, of Westwood, New Jersey. The status line reads that a Sections 8 and 15 combined declaration has been accepted and acknowledged, with a status date of June 2, 2026. The mark is an illustration drawing that includes words. The record describes the shape of a shield, with the words THE BEARD CLUB in stylized form centered inside the upper middle half of the shield, and a stylized beard and mustache centered inside the lower middle half. Color is not claimed as a feature of the mark, and the record disclaims BEARD CLUB apart from the mark as shown. The goods are beard trimmers, in International Class 008, U.S. Classes 023, 028, and 044, with a first use and a first use in commerce of January 2020.
The complaint alleges that Registration No. 5,944,306 for the BBS BEST BEARD STUFF mark is owned by Lexington Chang. It alleges that, in older registrations, including Registration No. 4,856,657 for the LC LEXINGTON CHANG MIAMI mark, Lexington Chang identified himself as Daniel Chang DBA Lexington Chang in the signatory section.
Pages presented as news or reviews
The complaint alleges that a consumer can land on at least six webpages the defendants host on bestbeardstuff.com, attached to the complaint as Exhibits A through F, each built to appear as a news article or an independent product review rather than an advertisement, with a headline, a summary, a narrative, and photographs offered as proof. It alleges that on two of the pages an author's name and a follower count also appear. It alleges, on information and belief, that the defendants created these articles. It alleges that the word Advertorial, when it appears, is in white type and often in an illegibly small size, and that no link on the Best Beard Stuff homepage leads to the six pages and no link on those pages leads back to the homepage.
The complaint alleges that Exhibits A through C tell a story about Best Beard Stuff products and a professional beard competition's 2025 championships that presents the products as validated by a governing body named on the pages. Exhibit A, the complaint alleges, tells that story about the Beard Growth Kit, and Exhibits B and C tell it about GROW XXL. It alleges, on information and belief, that the defendants concocted this story. It alleges that the institution they cite does not appear to exist and, on information and belief, that the competition they refer to did not take the action the pages describe. It alleges, on information and belief, that the event named on the pages does not exist, and it says that the real world championship competition for beards and moustaches is held every two years and was held in Pittsburgh in July 2025.
The complaint alleges, on information and belief, that the governing body named on the pages does not exist. It says the July 2025 championships were run by a different association, whose published rules restrict styling aids, hair coloring, fake facial hair, extensions, and structural add-ons, and do not restrict beard-growth products or mention the defendants. It alleges, on information and belief, that the events the pages describe did not happen and, on information and belief, that the named body could not have taken the actions the pages attribute to it. It alleges that the pages' account of the 2025 results is false. It alleges, on information and belief, that at least one photograph offered as a champion is an AI-generated image and does not depict the genuine 2025 champions. It alleges, on information and belief, that the news coverage and viral videos the pages describe do not exist. It alleges that the pages are indexed by search engines, that AI-powered answer tools repeat the defendants' account as fact, and that the defendants also spread the claims in social media ads.
The complaint alleges that Exhibit D is an article-style page for peppermint-oil products, including GROW XXL, formatted like a blog post with an author name and a follower count, in royal blue rather than the neon green of Best Beard Stuff product pages. It alleges that the page disparages traditional beard-growth oils and competing products, then introduces peppermint oil and markets GROW XXL. It alleges that Exhibit E is formatted as an independent comparison with no disclosure that it is an advertisement, and that its first image shows two The Beard Club products, with portions of the labels blurred, which the page disparages. It alleges that the yellow logo, bottle shape, cap, color scheme, and logo placement identify the products as The Beard Club's. It alleges that Exhibit F is another page with no advertisement disclosure, on a white background, with a byline presented as a doctor and a statement that a board-certified doctor verified the content, and that it promotes GROW XXL, crediting its peppermint oil. It alleges, on information and belief, that the person shown in the Week 1 photograph on Exhibit F is Daniel Chang.
The complaint alleges, on information and belief, that Daniel Chang markets Best Beard Stuff products on social media, including his personal TikTok account. It alleges that one video on that account disparages The Beard Club's beard oil and products, and that the video's claim about the oil is false and deceptive. It alleges that Best Beard Stuff also sponsors videos on a Facebook page whose Intro states that Best Beard Stuff is responsible for the page. It alleges, on information and belief, that the defendants operate or control that page. It alleges that in at least two advertisements on the page the speaker disparages the plaintiff's products, with the labels partly obscured but still identifiable as The Beard Club's, and that those videos make false and deceptive claims about the products.
The claims about the products
The complaint alleges that the defendants attribute the effectiveness of GROW XXL and other Best Beard Stuff products to peppermint oil, citing specific clinical figures for follicle growth, dermal thickness, and follicle count that the complaint says come from a fictitious government entity, along with a comparison to minoxidil. It alleges that product pages link a 2014 published study of peppermint oil and, on information and belief, that this is the paper behind the trials described in Exhibits A through D. It alleges that the paper does not support the product claims. It alleges that the cited figures were from mice, not humans: the researchers applied 3 percent peppermint oil to the backs of laboratory mice for four weeks, and the figures are a score for how much hair covered the mice's skin and measurements from mouse tissue. It alleges that the study had no human subjects and did not involve human facial hair, and that the paper does not substantiate the minoxidil comparison, even for mice. It alleges, on information and belief, that the government body the pages name does not exist. It alleges, on information and belief, that no clinical trial of peppermint oil for hair or beard growth has produced the results the defendants claim.
The complaint alleges that the defendants make superiority claims about their kits and GROW XXL, and specific claims about growth rate, follicle density, facial hair diameter, how soon results appear, relative strength, a review of clinical studies, and the share of consumers who see increased growth. It alleges, on information and belief, that these claims are not substantiated and are false. It alleges that an Amazon storefront displays user-result percentages attributed to a 2021 survey of U.S. respondents, and, on information and belief, that those claims are not substantiated and are false and deceptive. It alleges that product pages describe results of a 150-day clinical study without naming a journal, author, year, or institution, and, on information and belief, that those claims are not substantiated and are false and deceptive. It also alleges that the defendants sell a GROW First Cut Boar Bristle Beard & Wave Brush marketed as aiding beard growth, and that there is no scientific basis for claiming that brushing a beard increases the biological growth rate or creates new hair follicles. It alleges that two of The Beard Club's kits include a brush that is truthfully advertised as a grooming tool.
The complaint alleges that the defendants make claims of media coverage, market leadership, and a 2020 product award for Best Beard Stuff products and GROW XXL, and that the homepage at bestbeardstuff.com displays a Featured In section naming five publications. It alleges, on information and belief, that there was no such featured editorial coverage, that none of the five publications has published editorial coverage of Best Beard Stuff or GROW XXL, and that Best Beard Stuff received no such award from an independent third party. It alleges that Best Beard Stuff is not the market leader for beard-growth products. It alleges that product pages display all-natural, organic, and U.S.-origin badges, next to a round seal, between the description and the purchase links. It alleges, on information and belief, that none of the products advertised as organic is made entirely or nearly entirely from organically produced ingredients or certified as organic by any certifying body. It alleges, on information and belief, that the defendants advertise products that contain synthetic or chemically processed ingredients, including minoxidil. It alleges, on information and belief, that they apply the U.S.-origin claim to products that contain ingredients or components not grown or synthesized in the United States, or that were not assembled and packaged in the United States. It points, as an example, to gummies in the growth kits whose packaging does not carry that claim, while GROW XXL packaging does.
The website trade dress
The complaint alleges that The Beard Club presents its kits at thebeardclub.com through a distinctive combination of webpage elements, which it calls the Trade Dress. It describes a three-tier ladder of the Starter Kit, the Advanced Kit, and the Ultimate Kit. For each tier, it describes a purchase block with a product photograph, an Add to cart control, a parenthetical review count, and a See What's Inside link. It describes a disclosure headed What's Inside The [Tier] Kit, with the tier name in bold, and a repeating module of a product render on a plain background, a bold product name, and a one- to two-sentence description. It describes a guarantee block with a star review count in capitals, the headline BEARD GROWTH, GUARANTEED, and the line, No results using our regimen? You'll get a full refund with our Growth Guarantee. It describes a three-step How It Works sequence, Take the Quiz, Delivered to your door, and Enjoy your Beard, with the second step explained by, Easily manage monthly renewals, cancel anytime. It also describes a horizontal Featured In logo strip. The complaint alleges that these elements are non-functional, that The Beard Club has used the trade dress since 2018, and that the trade dress is inherently distinctive and has acquired secondary meaning.
The complaint alleges that the defendants copied that trade dress at https://bestbeardstuff.com/pages/beard-growth-kits and other pages on bestbeardstuff.com. It alleges that Best Beard Stuff sells three kits labeled Level 1, Level 2, and Level 3. It alleges, on information and belief, that the defendants created that three-tier structure by copying The Beard Club's trade dress. It alleges that image file names on the defendants' site use StarterKit, AdvancedKit, and UltimateKit. It alleges that each kit uses the same purchase-block pieces in the same order, including See What's Inside, and disclosure headings in the form What's Inside and the kit name. It quotes The Beard Club's derma-roller copy, Tiny micro-needles help to stimulate new facial hair growth, activate dormant hair follicles, and improve skin texture, and the defendants' roller copy, Tiny micro-needles help to stimulate new facial hair growth, activate dormant hair follicles, and boost serum absorption, and it alleges that the first thirteen words are identical. It alleges that The Beard Club's guarantee block displays 42,000+ 5-STAR REVIEWS, then BEARD GROWTH, GUARANTEED, then the regimen refund line, and that the defendants' block displays 13,000+ 5-STAR REVIEWS, then BEARD GROWTH GUARANTEED, then, No results in 30 days? You'll get a full refund with our Growth Guarantee. It alleges that Growth Guarantee is The Beard Club's name for its refund program, at thebeardclub.com/pages/growth-guarantee, and that the defendants use the same term. It alleges that the defendants' second How It Works step is headed DELIVERED TO YOUR DOOR, and that their third step carries the explanatory line Easily manage monthly renewals, cancel anytime, which the complaint says is The Beard Club's line word for word. It alleges, on information and belief, that the copying is deliberate.
The complaint alleges that the trade dress has acquired secondary meaning and that consumers associate it with The Beard Club. It alleges that numerous consumers have contacted The Beard Club believing they had purchased from The Beard Club, or that Best Beard Stuff products were The Beard Club's, and have tried to return those products or cancel subscriptions through The Beard Club. It alleges that the company's cost to acquire and keep customers has risen, that employee time is going to those contacts, and that goodwill is being eroded. It alleges that the defendants copied the trade dress deliberately, with the intent to confuse consumers, and that consumers are likely to believe that the defendants' site is the plaintiff's or that the defendants and their products are affiliated with, sponsored by, or endorsed by The Beard Club.
The four counts
The first count is false advertising under 15 U.S.C. § 1125(a)(1)(B), against all defendants. It alleges that each challenged claim is literally false or intentionally misleading, likely to deceive a substantial portion of the relevant consumers, made in interstate commerce, material, and likely to injure the plaintiff. It alleges false or misleading statements about the performance, efficacy, qualities, and comparative effectiveness of GROW XXL and related products, and about The Beard Club's products, including the statements in the TikTok video described above. It alleges injury through lost sales, diverted customers, increased customer-acquisition costs, price erosion, corrective-advertising expenses, and harm to reputation and goodwill, and it cites Lexmark Int'l, Inc. v. Static Control Components, Inc., 572 U.S. 118 (2014), for the zone of interests and proximate cause. It alleges entitlement to an injunction under 15 U.S.C. § 1116 and to actual damages, profits, enhanced profits and damages, costs, and reasonable attorneys' fees under 15 U.S.C. §§ 1116, 1117, and 1125, without double recovery. It alleges that the scale, specificity, intentionality, and continued dissemination of the claims support disgorgement, enhanced damages and profits, and attorneys' fees for an exceptional case.
The second count is trade dress infringement and false designation of origin under 15 U.S.C. § 1125(a)(1)(A), against all defendants. It alleges that The Beard Club owns prior rights in the website trade dress, that the trade dress is inherently distinctive and has acquired secondary meaning, and that the defendants' website and How It Works presentation are a false designation of origin and a representation likely to cause confusion as to source, sponsorship, or affiliation. It alleges actual confusion, including requests for refunds of products The Beard Club never sold or shipped. It seeks an injunction under 15 U.S.C. § 1116 and the same categories of monetary relief, without double recovery.
The third count is the Florida Deceptive and Unfair Trade Practices Act, Fla. Stat. § 501.201 et seq., against all defendants. It alleges unfair methods of competition and unconscionable, deceptive, and unfair acts in trade or commerce in Florida, including unsupported efficacy claims, false endorsements, source-confusing presentation, and targeted disparagement. It alleges that The Beard Club is a person who has suffered a loss under Fla. Stat. § 501.211(2), with damages to be proven at trial, and it seeks declaratory and injunctive relief under § 501.211(1), damages under § 501.211(2), and attorneys' fees and costs under Fla. Stat. § 501.2105. The fourth count is Florida common-law unfair competition, against all defendants. It alleges that the defendants used false efficacy and comparative claims, source-confusing presentation, targeted disparagement, and copied website elements to divert customers. It alleges that paragraphs 11, 12, 14, 15, 48, and 85 through 87 establish that Daniel Chang personally participated in, authorized, and directed the advertising, including the social media efficacy and disparagement claims, and that those allegations concern his own conduct, not passive ownership of the company.
The prayer
The prayer asks for judgment for the plaintiff on all causes of action. It asks the court to preliminarily and permanently enjoin the defendants, and their officers, agents, servants, employees, attorneys, and all persons in active concert or participation with them who receive actual notice of the order, from: making or causing to be made any of the false and misleading advertising claims described in the complaint; representing that GROW XXL or any Best Beard Stuff product was banned, restricted, or disqualified by any competition, governing body, or organization, or that any such body found any Best Beard Stuff product too effective to permit; representing that any study, clinical trial, government agency, institution, competition, publication, or award has established, validated, or endorsed the efficacy of any Best Beard Stuff product; representing that any such product produces any specified rate, percentage, or timeframe of hair or beard growth, follicle density, dermal thickness, or absorption, without competent and reliable scientific substantiation possessed before the representation is made; representing that The Beard Club's products cause skin irritation or any other adverse effect, are placebos, are ineffective, or are inferior to any Best Beard Stuff product, without competent and reliable scientific substantiation; representing that any Best Beard Stuff product is made, handcrafted, or manufactured in the United States unless all or virtually all of it is of United States origin; representing that any Best Beard Stuff product is all natural, organic, or made with organic ingredients, unless it is made with ingredients certified organic by an independent certifying body and contains no synthetic ingredients; representing that any Best Beard Stuff product is the number one selling, number one rated, or best-selling product in any market, without substantiation; publishing or causing to be published any advertisement formatted to resemble news reporting, independent journalism, or an independent product review without a clear and conspicuous disclosure that the content is the defendants' advertising; and using any website presentation, product descriptions, the term Growth Guarantee, or any other presentation or term confusingly similar to the trade dress.
The prayer also asks for an order requiring the defendants to remove the challenged advertising claims and infringing webpages wherever they appear in all forms, media, and channels the defendants own, control, or sponsor, including bestbeardstuff.com and all associated pages, including Exhibits A through F, Amazon, TikTok, Instagram, Facebook, and other social platforms; to remove the content at the URLs for Exhibits A through F and replace it with corrective advertising under 15 U.S.C. § 1116(a); and to undertake corrective advertising under that section that is clear, conspicuous, and reasonably calculated to reach consumers exposed to the challenged campaign through all e-commerce and marketing channels in which the defendants made the deceptive claims, and to correct the false or misleading efficacy, competition, scientific, institutional, media, award, composition, origin, pricing, and comparison claims. It asks that the defendants file with the court and serve on the plaintiff's counsel, within thirty days after entry of judgment, a written report under oath setting forth in detail the manner and form in which they have complied with the injunction and corrective-advertising order. It asks the court to authorize the plaintiff to serve a copy of the order on any service provider hosting or distributing the enjoined content, and to direct those providers to disable access to content the defendants fail to remove. It asks for an accounting and payment of profits, and for discovery and an evidentiary hearing on sales, revenues, profits, and damages. It asks for monetary relief in an amount to be determined at trial, but in no event less than $500,000, including actual damages, the defendants' profits, enhanced or treble damages and enhanced profits as permitted by law, costs, and reasonable attorneys' fees under 15 U.S.C. §§ 1116 and 1117, this being an exceptional case. It asks for declaratory and injunctive relief, actual damages, and fees and costs under Fla. Stat. §§ 501.211 and 501.2105, and for all damages and equitable relief available for the unfair-competition and product-disparagement claims, plus pre- and post-judgment interest and other relief the court deems just and proper. The complaint demands a jury trial under Rule 38(a) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. The case can end at any time, including by settlement or voluntary dismissal.