The complaint
EcoWater Systems LLC v. Garth O. Green Enterprises, Inc., No. 1:26-cv-14228 (N.D. Ill.), is a 19-page complaint filed November 16, 2026, as ECF No. 1, with a demand for a jury trial on all issues triable to a jury. The complaint says it is made on knowledge as to EcoWater and its own acts and on information and belief as to all other matters. EcoWater Systems LLC is a Delaware limited liability company with its principal place of business in Woodbury, Minnesota. The defendant is Garth O. Green Enterprises, Inc., a Utah corporation doing business as PlumbersStock.com, with its principal place of business in Cedar City, Utah. The complaint alleges that the defendant operates an e-commerce website at www.plumbersstock.com and is an online seller of plumbing, heating and cooling, kitchen and bath, and other home-improvement products, serving professionals and homeowners. The case is assigned to Judge Andrea R. Wood.
The marks
The complaint pleads that EcoWater owns U.S. registrations for ECOWATER and ECOWATER SYSTEMS, which it calls the EcoWater Marks, and for ECO PURE marks, and it names four registrations. TSDR lists EcoWater Systems LLC as the owner of each, on the Principal Register. Reg. No. 1,555,661, ECOWATER, is a standard-character trademark registered September 12, 1989, in Class 11, for "WATER TREATMENT EQUIPMENT AND PARTS THEREOF, NAMELY - RESIDENTIAL WATER CONDITIONERS, DOMESTIC REVERSE OSMOSIS WATER PURIFIERS, AND FILTERS, ION EXCHANGERS AND DEGASIFIERS FOR TREATING LIQUIDS." TSDR states that the registration has been renewed, and it records a Section 15 acknowledgment on June 28, 1995. Reg. No. 1,771,860, ECOWATER SYSTEMS, is a standard-character service mark registered May 18, 1993, in Class 37, for "repair and maintenance services in the field of domestic and commercial water treatment equipment; namely, water conditioners, softeners, deionizers, distillers, filters, and related water treatment units." TSDR states that the registration has been renewed, and it records a Section 15 acknowledgment on September 29, 1999. Reg. No. 1,585,509, ECO PURE, is a standard-character trademark registered March 6, 1990, in Class 11, for "WATER PURIFICATION AND FILTRATION UNITS FOR DOMESTIC AND COMMERCIAL USE." TSDR states that the registration has been renewed, and it records a Section 15 acknowledgment on December 5, 1995. Reg. No. 5,751,473, ECOPURE, is a trademark and service mark registered May 14, 2019. TSDR shows it as an illustration drawing rather than a standard-character mark, describes it as the term "ECOPURE" with a single water drop between the "U" and the "R," and states that color is not claimed. The Class 11 goods are "Water treatment equipment, namely, water conditioning units, water softening units, water purifiers, water deionizers, water distillers, water filters; water refiners, namely, water conditioning units comprised of water softening and carbon filtration technology; water treatment equipment, namely, reverse-osmosis units for domestic and commercial use; structural parts, structural installation parts and accessories for water softening units, water treatment equipment and water filtration equipment; drinking water systems, namely, undersink water filtration units; filtration cartridges; water filtration pitchers sold empty; water filtration units sold as a component part of portable water filtration pitchers sold empty." The Class 35 services are "Providing consumer information in the field of water treatment goods and services." TSDR states that a Sections 8 and 15 combined declaration has been accepted and acknowledged, and it records the Section 15 acknowledgment on September 19, 2025.
The complaint alleges that each of those registrations is valid and subsisting and has become incontestable under 15 U.S.C. § 1065, and that the registrations are conclusive evidence of validity, of EcoWater's ownership, and of its exclusive right to use the marks in commerce on the goods and services identified in the registrations, citing 15 U.S.C. § 1115(b). It alleges that EcoWater and its predecessors-in-interest have continuously and exclusively used the ECOWATER and ECOWATER SYSTEMS marks for many decades.
What the complaint alleges
The complaint alleges that ECOWATER-branded products are sold, installed, and serviced through a network of authorized dealers, that only those authorized dealers are permitted to market and sell ECOWATER-branded products, and that the dealers are bound by written agreements covering marketing, warranty administration, installation, and customer service. It alleges that consumers who purchase ECOWATER-branded products through an authorized dealer are able to receive in-home consultation and water analysis, professional installation, ongoing service and support from the dealer, and the ECOWATER warranty. It alleges that ECOPURE is a separate line, including models designated EP31, EP42, and EPHS, designed for consumer installation and sold through retail channels, with its own warranty and support, rather than through the ECOWATER dealer network.
The complaint alleges that the defendant is reselling what appear to be ECOPURE-branded water softeners, and that it falsely labels and promotes them as ECOWATER products. It alleges that each product, as shown in the listing images, bears an ECOPURE mark and does not bear an ECOWATER mark, and that the model numbers EPHS, EP7130, and EP7140 are ECOPURE model designations. It alleges that the defendant's own description of the EPHS refers to the product as "The EcoPure EPHS." It gives, as examples of listings the website has offered, an EPHS water softener and filter at $1,170.53, an EP7130 water softener at $989.73, and an EP7140 water softener at $1,058.61. It alleges that the EP7140 listing is titled "Ecowater 40k Grain Cabinet Water Softener - EP7140" and identifies the manufacturer as "Ecowater"; that the EPHS listing is titled "ECOWATER EPHS WATER SOFTNER AND FILTER" and identifies the manufacturer as "Ecowater"; and that the EP7130 listing is titled "Ecowater Water Softener, 30000 Grains - EP7130." It alleges that the web addresses for the EPHS and EP7140 listings are www.plumbersstock.com/ecowater-ephs.html and www.plumbersstock.com/ecowater-ep7140.html, and that none of those titles or web addresses refers to ECOPURE. Those listings, together with every other listing on the website that identifies a product as an "Ecowater" or ECOWATER product, are what the complaint calls the accused listings.
The complaint alleges that the defendant is not an authorized EcoWater dealer, and that EcoWater has not licensed or otherwise authorized the defendant to use the EcoWater Marks, including as a brand name, product title, or manufacturer designation for products that are not sold under those marks, or to advertise or sell any product as an ECOWATER product. It alleges that, by placing the marks first and most prominently in each listing title and identifying "Ecowater" in the manufacturer field of products that bear the ECOPURE mark, the defendant presents the marks as the brand under which the products are sold, rather than merely identifying who made them. On information and belief, it alleges that the defendant has sold and shipped products, including products at issue in this case, to customers in Illinois. On information and belief, it alleges that the defendant's use of the marks in the titles, manufacturer fields, and web addresses causes the accused listings to appear in response to internet searches by consumers seeking ECOWATER-branded products, diverting those consumers from EcoWater's authorized dealers and trading on the goodwill of the marks. It alleges a likelihood that consumers searching for, or expecting, ECOWATER-branded products will believe that the products the defendant sells are ECOWATER-line products that come with the dealer-based consultation, installation, service, and warranty support associated with the ECOWATER brand, and that the defendant is affiliated with, or authorized by, EcoWater and its dealer network.
The complaint alleges that on October 2, 2026, EcoWater sent the defendant a letter objecting to the use of the marks in the accused listings. The letter asked the defendant, within two weeks, to remove or suspend those listings, to identify the source of the products, and to confirm in writing that it would not represent that it is an authorized EcoWater dealer or that its products carry EcoWater's manufacturer's warranty or authorized service support. The complaint alleges that the defendant did not respond by the October 16, 2026 deadline, has not responded since, and that as of the date of the complaint the accused listings remained on the website. It alleges that authorized dealers have reported to EcoWater that the listings are causing confusion about the availability, pricing, sourcing, and warranty status of ECOWATER-branded products, and it says those reports reflect actual marketplace confusion caused by the listings.
The claims and the prayer
The five counts, each brought by EcoWater against the defendant, are: (I) federal trademark infringement under 15 U.S.C. § 1114(1); (II) false designation of origin and federal unfair competition under 15 U.S.C. § 1125(a)(1)(A); (III) false advertising under 15 U.S.C. § 1125(a)(1)(B); (IV) deceptive trade practices under the Illinois Uniform Deceptive Trade Practices Act, 815 ILCS 510/2(a)(2), (3), (5), and (12); and (V) common law trademark infringement and unfair competition. The complaint alleges that the unauthorized use is willful and intentional infringement. On information and belief, it alleges that the defendant knew the products it sells are ECOPURE-branded products, and it alleges that the defendant continued the use after the October 2, 2026 letter. It alleges that this is an exceptional case under 15 U.S.C. § 1117(a). On the false advertising count, it alleges that the accused listings falsely or misleadingly describe ECOPURE-branded products as ECOWATER products by titling them with "Ecowater," listing "Ecowater" in the manufacturer field, and presenting them as products of the ECOWATER line, without disclosing that they are ECOPURE-line products that are not sold, installed, or supported through the dealer network. It alleges that the statements are material because brand, product line, and the availability of dealer consultation, installation, service, and warranty support are "likely to influence" consumers' decisions to purchase a water treatment system, a purchase it says typically costs hundreds of dollars or more.
The prayer asks for a judgment that the defendant has willfully, and with intent to cause confusion, mistake, or deception: infringed the EcoWater Marks under 15 U.S.C. § 1114(1); used false designations of origin under 15 U.S.C. § 1125(a)(1)(A); engaged in false advertising under 15 U.S.C. § 1125(a)(1)(B); engaged in deceptive trade practices under 815 ILCS 510/2; and violated EcoWater's common law rights in the marks and engaged in common law unfair competition. It asks for a preliminary and permanent injunction against the defendant and its affiliates, officers, agents, employees, attorneys, and other persons acting in concert with it, barring: transporting, promoting, advertising, publicizing, distributing, offering for sale, or selling any products or services under the EcoWater Marks and any colorable imitations thereof, and/or any other marks, names, symbols, or logos "which are likely to cause confusion or to cause mistake or to deceive persons into the erroneous belief that any products or services that Defendant causes to enter the stream of commerce or any of Defendant's commercial activities are sponsored or licensed by EcoWater, are authorized by EcoWater, or are connected or affiliated in some way with EcoWater or the EcoWater Marks"; use of the marks, colorable imitations, or confusingly similar marks as a brand name, product title, manufacturer designation, search keyword, or web address in connection with the advertisement, offer for sale, or sale of any products that are not sold under the EcoWater Marks; representations, express or implied, that the defendant is an authorized EcoWater dealer, or that products not sold under the marks, including ECOPURE-branded products, are ECOWATER products or are sold, installed, or supported through the dealer network, and any other false or misleading description or representation of fact concerning the brand, line, source, or characteristics of products the defendant sells; implying EcoWater's approval, endorsement, or sponsorship of, or affiliation or connection with, the defendant's products, services, or commercial activities, passing off the defendant's business as EcoWater's, or unfair methods of competition with EcoWater and other interference with or injury to the marks or the goodwill associated with them; and knowingly assisting, inducing, aiding, or abetting any other person or business in those acts. It also asks for a sworn report, under 15 U.S.C. § 1116(a), filed with the Court and served on EcoWater within 30 days after service of an injunction, setting forth the manner and form of compliance; an order authorizing EcoWater to effectuate compliance at the defendant's sole cost and expense if the defendant fails to comply; an order requiring the defendant to remove or correct the accused listings and any other listing, advertisement, or promotional material that does not comply with the injunction, so that they do not use the marks or colorable imitations as a brand name, product title, manufacturer designation, web address, metadata, search keyword, or paid search advertisement for products not sold under the marks, on the defendant's website and on any other website, marketplace, or channel the defendant controls or uses, to request that search engines and marketplaces remove cached or indexed copies of the accused listings, and, under 15 U.S.C. § 1118, to deliver up for destruction all labels, signs, advertisements, and promotional materials in its possession that bear the marks and violate the injunction. It asks for an accounting of all sales of products made through listings that use the marks or colorable imitations; a judgment that EcoWater is the exclusive owner of the marks and that the marks are valid and protectable; damages, including the cost of corrective advertising, in an amount to be proven at trial; the defendant's profits under 15 U.S.C. § 1117(a); enhanced damages of up to three times EcoWater's actual damages under 15 U.S.C. § 1117(a); costs, disbursements, and attorneys' fees under 15 U.S.C. § 1117(a) and 815 ILCS 510/3; punitive damages under the common law for willful and wanton conduct; pre-judgment interest; and other relief the Court deems just and proper.
What to watch next
Watch for an answer or a Rule 12 motion. The case can end at any time, including by settlement or voluntary dismissal.