The complaint
Graco Inc. and Graco Minnesota Inc. v. Bedford Precision Parts LLC, No. 1:26-cv-01471 (D. Del.), is a 46-page complaint filed November 16, 2026, as ECF No. 1, with a jury demand. It says Graco Inc. and its wholly owned subsidiary Graco Minnesota Inc. are Minnesota corporations, each with a place of business in Minneapolis, Minnesota, and that Bedford Precision Parts LLC is a Delaware limited liability company with a place of business in Bedford Hills, New York, that is in the business of manufacturing, importing, selling, and/or offering for sale replacement parts intended for use in the products of original equipment manufacturers such as Graco. The complaint alleges, upon information and belief, that Bedford sells the products at issue to purchasers of Graco products for use in Graco-branded products, and that it sells them throughout the United States through its own website and through various third parties.
The marks
The complaint pleads nine registrations on the Principal Register that it calls the Graco Trademarks and says Graco Minnesota Inc. obtained: GRACO, Reg. No. 844,517, registered February 20, 1968, for goods including pressurized fluid spraying systems for spraying paints, fluid pumping systems, and spray guns and parts thereof; a stylized G with GRACO, Reg. No. 5,379,715, registered January 16, 2018, for goods including airless paint sprayers and electrostatic paint spray coating guns; a color mark, Reg. No. 7,666,230, registered January 28, 2025, for tips for paint spray guns; ULTRA, Reg. No. 1,418,183, registered November 25, 1986, for electronic paint sprayers; KING, Reg. No. 3,907,639, registered January 18, 2011, for positive displacement pumps; GMAX, Reg. No. 5,497,958, registered June 19, 2018, for gas mechanical airless spraying equipment; FF LP, Reg. No. 5,636,556, registered December 25, 2018, for tips for paint spray guns; XTREME, Reg. No. 2,919,292, registered January 18, 2005, for reciprocating piston pumps for use with paint and coatings; and LINELAZER, Reg. No. 3,933,935, registered March 22, 2011, for a power-operated airless sprayer for applying markings to pavement or turf.
The complaint says the color mark, which it calls the Blue Tip Mark, consists of "the color blue applied to the entire outer surface of the non-metallic portion of a tip for a paint spray gun," and that Graco has used blue on its spray tips since at least as early as January 2003. The complaint says the mark registered under Section 2(f) after the USPTO determined it had acquired distinctiveness. It also points to a separate registration, Reg. No. 3,300,390, for the color blue on the housing of Graco's portable airless paint sprayers, and says Graco has used blue on its paint sprayers since at least 1967.
To support the Blue Tip Mark, the complaint cites Graco's brand identity guidelines, which it quotes as saying that "blue should be the featured primary color in all communications," advertising that tells buyers to "look for blue" when buying spray tips, and more than two decades of what it calls substantially exclusive and continuous use. It alleges that blue is not a natural byproduct of making spray tips, and that at least one competitor uses red, among other colors, for its tips but not blue.
What the complaint alleges
The complaint alleges that Bedford uses a confusingly similar, if not identical, Blue Tip Mark in connection with competing paint spray tips, and that it uses FF LP to market competing spray tips both in its product listings and, for at least some products, on the packaging itself, including packaging for a product bought on Amazon. It alleges that the spray tips move through the same channels as Graco's, including the parties' websites, third-party retailers such as Amazon, and brick-and-mortar stores, and that they are marketed to the same types of consumers.
On the website, the complaint alleges that almost every Bedford listing for a product compatible with or replacing a GRACO-branded product uses GRACO in the listing. Its example is a listing titled "Graco LTX417 Replacement Spray Tip," where, it says, Bedford's own product name appears lower on the page, below the "Add to cart" button and in smaller type. It alleges that GRACO comes first in the title and the page address without language signaling that the product is not a Graco product, and that Bedford uses more of the mark than needed to describe compatibility. It says the same pattern extends to GMAX, ULTRA, KING, XTREME, and LINELAZER, that some listings advertise a product as "Bedford Precision's XTREME," and that buyers can add products to their carts without reaching the main product page. It alleges that, at a minimum, the use is likely to cause initial interest confusion.
For actual confusion, the complaint cites a consumer comment on a sponsored Bedford Facebook advertisement asking whether Graco makes Bedford, and a November 13, 2026 message to Graco's Facebook business account asking whether a Bedford FFLP tip could be used on the sender's "blue rac X guard," which the complaint says wrongly associates the FF LP mark with Bedford. It alleges, upon information and belief, that Bedford adopted the marks with the intent to confuse consumers, that its acts have been willful by virtue of at least its actual knowledge of Graco's trademark rights, and that it began its use of the Blue Tip and FF LP marks despite knowing that the use was in contravention of Graco's rights. The complaint also alleges that a Graco website image of a professional using a Graco paint sprayer appears on Bedford's website.
The claims and the prayer
Count I pleads federal trademark infringement under Section 32(1) of the Lanham Act, 15 U.S.C. § 1114(1), and in the alternative alleges initial interest confusion. Count II pleads unfair competition and false designation of origin under Section 43(a) of the Lanham Act, 15 U.S.C. § 1125(a). Count III pleads common law trademark infringement, and Count IV pleads unfair competition, each under the common law of the various states, including Delaware. Counts V and VI plead infringement of U.S. Patent No. 10,502,206 and U.S. Design Patent No. D742,927 by Bedford's Piston Rod and Valve, Part No. 57-3530, and Count VII pleads copyright infringement over the website image.
The prayer asks for a permanent injunction against directly or indirectly infringing the Graco Trademarks; passing off, or inducing or enabling others to sell or pass off, any product or service as or for products or services rendered by Graco that are not Graco's or are not rendered by or under the control or supervision of Graco and approved by Graco; directly or indirectly engaging in any acts or activities calculated to trade upon the Graco Trademarks or Graco's reputation or goodwill, or in any manner to compete with Graco unfairly; using in the sale, offering for sale, promotion, advertising, marketing, or distribution of its merchandise or services the Graco Trademarks, or any mark or trade name that includes them or simulates, imitates, or is confusingly similar to them, so as to deceive, to falsely describe or represent the source of the services, or otherwise to create confusion among the purchasing public or the trade; further violating Graco's property rights and goodwill; directly or indirectly infringing Graco's copyrights; and otherwise competing unfairly with Graco in any manner. It asks that Bedford deliver up to Graco for destruction, at Bedford's expense, all packaging, labels, signs, promotional materials, advertisements, and other communications to the public in its possession or under its control bearing material or representations that are or may be false or misleading about the source or origin of its products and services, to the extent they are used in connection with sales or offers for sale of goods bearing the Graco Trademarks in the United States. It also asks for judgments that Bedford directly infringed one or more claims of U.S. Patent No. 10,502,206 and the D742,927 design patent; trademark damages, including Graco's actual damages and disgorgement of Bedford's profits under 15 U.S.C. § 1117, enhanced up to three times Graco's actual damages for willful infringement; copyright damages, including Graco's actual damages, under 17 U.S.C. § 504; patent damages of no less than a reasonable royalty under 35 U.S.C. §§ 284 and/or 289; a finding that the case is exceptional, with attorneys' fees and other recoverable expenses under 15 U.S.C. § 1117 and/or 35 U.S.C. § 285, and costs; pre-judgment and post-judgment interest; and other relief the court deems just and proper.
The patent counts are covered at patentlitigator.com/analysis/graco-v-bedford-precision-pump-rod-patents-trademarks-copyright-ddel/, and the copyright count at copyrightnow.com/news/graco-v-bedford-precision-parts-paint-sprayer-image-copyright-complaint-ddel/.
The case can end at any time, including by settlement or voluntary dismissal.