The complaint
Burkhardt v. Red Roper Club, LTD, No. 2:26-cv-02181 (W.D. Ark.), is an 18-page complaint filed November 17, 2026, in the Fort Smith Division, as Document 2. The complaint itself is dated November 16, 2026. The caption demands a jury trial, and the complaint demands a trial by jury on all issues so triable. Docket entry 2 records the filing as a complaint with a jury demand, entered November 17, 2026. (Compl. caption, p. 18 date line, and jury demand; docket entry 2.)
The nine plaintiffs, and the way the complaint describes each of them, are Monica Leigh Burkhardt, a professional model and actress and a resident of Suffolk County, New York; John Coulter, a professional model and performer and a resident of Los Angeles County, California; Jamillette Gaxiola, a professional model and sports personality and a resident of Clark County, Nevada; Jessica Hinton a/k/a Jessa Hinton, a professional model, actress, and television personality and a resident of Los Angeles County, California; Brooke Johnson a/k/a Brooke Taylor, a professional model and a resident of Santa Barbara County, California; Carrie Minter, a professional model and actress and a resident of Los Angeles County, California; Eva Pepaj, a professional model, actress, and content creator and a resident of Los Angeles County, California; Katarina Van Derham, a professional model, actress, entrepreneur, and publisher and a resident of Los Angeles County, California; and Irina Voronina, a professional model, actress, and entertainer and a resident of Los Angeles County, California. The complaint refers to Jessica Hinton as Hinton, to Brooke Johnson as Taylor, and to Katarina Van Derham as Van Derham. (Compl. paras. 19-27.)
Red Roper Club, LTD d/b/a Electric Cowboy of Fort Smith is an Arkansas corporation authorized to conduct business in Arkansas. The complaint says it operated and promoted the Electric Cowboy nightclub in Fort Smith, Arkansas, which the complaint calls Fort Smith. Electric Cowboy of Fayetteville, Inc. d/b/a Whiskey 101 is an Arkansas corporation authorized to conduct business in Arkansas. The complaint says it operated and promoted the Whiskey 101 nightclub in Fayetteville, Arkansas, which the complaint calls Whiskey 101. Electric Cowboy of Little Rock, Inc. d/b/a Electric Cowboy Little Rock is an Arkansas corporation authorized to conduct business in Arkansas. The complaint says it operated and promoted the Electric Cowboy nightclub in Little Rock, Arkansas, which the complaint calls Little Rock. The complaint refers to the three locations together as the Nightclubs and to the three operating entities as the Electric Cowboy Defendants. MLT Management, Inc., which the complaint calls MLT Inc., is a Texas corporation registered to transact business in Arkansas. MLT Management, LLC, which the complaint calls MLT LLC, is a Texas limited liability company. Together the complaint calls them the MLT Defendants. The complaint alleges, upon information and belief, that MLT LLC is associated with the management, branding, marketing, and advertising of Electric Cowboy locations, including the Nightclubs. (Compl. caption and paras. 2-5, 28-32.)
The advertising the complaint describes
The complaint says the action arises from a coordinated and recurring marketing program used to promote three Arkansas nightclubs in the same Electric Cowboy chain: Electric Cowboy of Fort Smith, Whiskey 101 in Fayetteville, and Electric Cowboy Little Rock. It alleges that the defendants used the plaintiffs' commercially valuable names, images, likenesses, identities, and apparent endorsements, which it calls the Images, in social-media advertisements without the plaintiffs' authorization or compensation. It alleges that the challenged uses were part of the same series of transactions and occurrences: a chain-wide practice of acquiring professional-model imagery, incorporating that imagery into standardized promotional advertisements, and publishing those advertisements through commonly managed nightclub social-media accounts to attract patrons. It alleges that the common series is confirmed by, among other things, overlapping plaintiffs, the use of the same model collage and the same or materially identical "$1,000 Couples Contest" creative by Fort Smith and Whiskey 101 during the same 2016-2017 campaign period, common Electric Cowboy branding, common management connections, and the recurring use of the same marketing method at Little Rock. (Compl. paras. 1, 6, 7.)
The complaint alleges, upon information and belief, that the MLT Defendants participated in the management and marketing of the Nightclubs through shared owners, officers, directors, managers, marketing personnel, vendors, policies, practices, and digital-marketing resources, and that the MLT Defendants and the Electric Cowboy Defendants used a common Electric Cowboy brand and a common marketing system to select, prepare, distribute, and publish nightclub advertisements through Facebook, Instagram, and related channels. It alleges, upon information and belief, that one or both MLT Defendants provided or supervised management services for the Nightclubs, including marketing direction, access to shared promotional resources, administration or oversight of social-media accounts, and coordination or dissemination of advertising content. It alleges, upon information and belief, that one or both MLT Defendants and the Electric Cowboy Defendants maintained a common practice of obtaining professional-model imagery without negotiating licenses with the depicted models, incorporating the imagery into advertisements for nightclub events and promotions, and publishing the advertisements through commonly managed social-media accounts. (Compl. paras. 5, 36, 37.)
The complaint alleges that the Nightclubs operated as parts of the same Electric Cowboy business network, with common branding and similar social-media channels, and that the Electric Cowboy Defendants operated or controlled the social-media accounts used to promote their respective Nightclubs. It alleges that the MLT Defendants and the Electric Cowboy Defendants used those accounts and the challenged advertisements for their own commercial and financial benefit, including attracting patrons and promoting events, services, and alcohol sales. It alleges that the defendants used and altered the plaintiffs' Images in advertising in a manner that falsely conveyed that the plaintiffs worked at, endorsed, approved, sponsored, or were otherwise associated or affiliated with the Nightclubs and their events. It alleges that those apparent associations were false, and that no plaintiff worked at a Nightclub, endorsed a Nightclub or a defendant, authorized the challenged advertising, or agreed to appear at the advertised events. It alleges that the defendants did not negotiate with, obtain a commercial license from, or pay any plaintiff for the challenged uses. It says the plaintiffs do not allege that every Electric Cowboy Defendant published every plaintiff's Image. Each plaintiff asserts claims against the MLT Defendants and only the Electric Cowboy Defendant or Defendants identified for that plaintiff below. (Compl. paras. 18, 35, 41-44.)
Which nightclub the complaint assigns to each plaintiff
The complaint's plaintiff and exhibit map assigns each plaintiff to particular nightclubs.
- The complaint alleges that Fort Smith used an image of Monica Leigh Burkhardt, whom it describes as having modeled for national publications and having appeared in commercial entertainment and promotional media, in advertising published through Fort Smith's Facebook account.
- The complaint alleges that Fort Smith and Whiskey 101 used images of John Coulter, whom it describes as having modeled for national fashion, apparel, cosmetic, and entertainment campaigns and having appeared in major commercial productions, in advertising. It points to Fort Smith Facebook advertisements and Whiskey 101 Facebook advertisements.
- The complaint alleges that Little Rock used images of Jamillette Gaxiola, whom it describes as having modeled for national and international fashion brands and having worked as a sports personality, in advertising published through Little Rock's Facebook and Instagram accounts.
- The complaint alleges that Whiskey 101 used an image of Jessica Hinton a/k/a Jessa Hinton, whom it describes as having worked in national advertising, print modeling, television, and commercial spokesperson roles, in advertising published through Whiskey 101's Facebook account.
- The complaint alleges that Fort Smith used an image of Brooke Johnson a/k/a Brooke Taylor, whom it describes as having appeared in national magazines, commercial campaigns, catalogs, and television advertising, in advertising published through Fort Smith's Facebook account.
- The complaint alleges that Fort Smith and Whiskey 101 used images of Carrie Minter, whom it describes as having modeled for major designers and having appeared in national magazines, advertising campaigns, film, television, and commercial media, in advertising. It points to Fort Smith Facebook advertisements and to Whiskey 101 Facebook and Instagram advertisements.
- The complaint alleges that Little Rock used images of Eva Pepaj, whom it describes as having worked in high-fashion, print, film, national television advertising, and digital content creation, in advertising published through Little Rock's Facebook account.
- The complaint alleges that Little Rock used images of Katarina Van Derham, whom it describes as having appeared in national and international modeling and advertising campaigns, having served as a commercial spokesperson, and having founded a glamour and lifestyle publication, in advertising published through Little Rock's Facebook and Instagram accounts on December 18, 2025. The complaint says the challenged uses allegedly appropriated and injured the commercial value of her identity, reputation, goodwill, and licensing and endorsement rights.
- The complaint alleges that Fort Smith and Whiskey 101 used images of Irina Voronina, whom it describes as having represented national and international consumer brands and having appeared extensively in print, television, film, promotional, and digital media, in advertising. It points to Fort Smith Facebook advertisements and to Whiskey 101 Facebook and Instagram advertisements.
The three counts
The first cause of action is headed as a violation of section 43 of the Lanham Act, 15 U.S.C. § 1125(a)(1)(A), for false association. The complaint alleges that each plaintiff asserts this claim against the MLT Defendants and the Electric Cowboy Defendant or Defendants identified for that plaintiff in the map. It alleges that the defendants used the plaintiffs' Images in advertising in a manner likely to convey to the public that the plaintiffs worked at, endorsed, sponsored, approved, or were associated with the Nightclubs and their events, that the defendants used the advertisements in interstate commerce, and that the unauthorized uses were likely to cause consumers to believe that the plaintiffs sponsored, approved, worked at, appeared at, or were associated with the Nightclubs. It alleges that each plaintiff's identity has acquired commercial value and serves to identify that plaintiff as the source of her or his professional modeling and endorsement services. It alleges that each MLT Defendant is directly liable because, upon information and belief, it participated in, coordinated, administered, or exercised control over the common advertising system and the challenged uses. It says the plaintiffs plead the MLT Defendants' respective participation in the alternative and seek to hold each only for its own conduct and conduct legally attributable to it, and that each Electric Cowboy Defendant is liable for advertisements promoting its Nightclub. The count seeks actual damages under 15 U.S.C. § 1117(a), an accounting and the defendants' profits, any adjustment or enhancement the court finds just and compensatory under § 1117(a), costs, attorneys' fees upon a showing that this is an exceptional case, prejudgment and post-judgment interest, and other relief. (Compl. paras. 67-73, 76, 77.)
The second cause of action is headed as a violation of section 43 of the Lanham Act, 15 U.S.C. § 1125(a)(1)(B), for false advertising. The complaint alleges that each plaintiff asserts this claim against the MLT Defendants and the same applicable Electric Cowboy Defendants. It alleges that the advertisements conveyed that the plaintiffs worked at or were affiliated with the Nightclubs, endorsed the Nightclubs or their events, consented to the use, or would participate in or appear at the promoted events, and that those representations were false and misleading. It alleges that the representations were made in commercial advertising or promotion, that they were material, and that the advertisements entered interstate commerce through Facebook, Instagram, and the Nightclubs' digital marketing channels. It alleges that each MLT Defendant is directly liable because, upon information and belief, it participated in, coordinated, administered, or exercised control over the common advertising system and the challenged uses, again pleaded in the alternative and limited to each defendant's own conduct and conduct legally attributable to it. It alleges actual commercial damages in an amount to be determined at trial, including proven lost or impaired licensing and endorsement income and opportunities, commercial injury to reputation and goodwill, diminution in the commercial value of their identities, reasonable corrective-advertising or remediation expenses, and the fair market value of the licensing and endorsement rights appropriated by the defendants, alternatively measured by a reasonable license fee or reasonable royalty for the scope and duration of each challenged use. (Compl. paras. 80-85, 87, 88.)
The third cause of action is headed as a violation of California Civil Code § 3344, for unauthorized commercial use of a photograph and likeness, as to plaintiff Van Derham only. The complaint alleges that only Katarina Van Derham brings this claim, and only against the MLT Defendants and Electric Cowboy of Little Rock, Inc. d/b/a Electric Cowboy Little Rock, which this count calls the Little Rock Defendants. It pleads that California law governs because she is a California resident, because she sustained injury in California to the commercial value of her identity and her licensing and endorsement rights, and because California has a substantial interest in protecting those interests. It alleges, upon information and belief, that on December 18, 2025, the Little Rock Defendants knowingly selected, incorporated, and used her photograph and likeness in Facebook and Instagram advertisements promoting Little Rock, its events, and its services. It alleges that she did not consent in writing or otherwise. For this claim, the complaint says, Van Derham alleges that the Little Rock Defendants knowingly used advertising materials containing her photograph and likeness. She does not allege that they intended to violate § 3344 or intended to cause her injury. She seeks the greater of $750 or her actual damages, attributable profits not included in computing actual damages, injunctive relief, reasonable attorneys' fees and costs, interest, and other relief under that statute, without double recovery. (Compl. paras. 90-96, 98.)
The prayer and the jury demand
The plaintiffs ask for judgment in their favor and against the applicable defendants, as follows:
- (a) The plaintiffs' actual damages under 15 U.S.C. § 1117(a), including proven lost or impaired licensing and endorsement income and opportunities; commercial injury to reputation and goodwill; diminution in the commercial value of the plaintiffs' identities; reasonable corrective-advertising or remediation expenses; and the fair market value of the licensing and endorsement rights appropriated by the defendants, alternatively measured by a reasonable license fee or reasonable royalty for the scope and duration of each challenged use.
- (b) An accounting and the defendants' profits attributable to the violations under 15 U.S.C. § 1117(a), separately and in addition to or as an alternative to the plaintiffs' damages to the extent permitted without double recovery.
- (c) Costs and, upon a showing that this is an exceptional case, reasonable attorneys' fees under 15 U.S.C. § 1117(a).
- (d) Prejudgment and post-judgment interest as permitted by law.
- (e) Any adjustment or enhancement of damages or profits that the court finds just and compensatory under 15 U.S.C. § 1117(a).
- (f) For Katarina Van Derham, relief under California Civil Code § 3344 against the MLT Defendants and Little Rock, including the greater of $750 or her actual damages, attributable profits not included in computing actual damages, injunctive relief, reasonable attorneys' fees and costs, prejudgment and post-judgment interest, and all other relief available under that statute, without double recovery.
- (g) Such other and further relief as the court deems just and proper.
The injunctive relief in paragraph (f) is asked for under California Civil Code § 3344, for Katarina Van Derham. The complaint demands a trial by jury on all issues so triable. The case can end at any time, including by settlement or voluntary dismissal. (Compl. prayer (a)-(g) and jury demand.)
Jurisdiction and venue
The complaint pleads subject-matter jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1331 because the plaintiffs assert claims under section 43(a) of the Lanham Act, 15 U.S.C. § 1125(a), and supplemental jurisdiction over Van Derham's California Civil Code § 3344 claim under 28 U.S.C. § 1367. It alleges that the Electric Cowboy Defendants are Arkansas entities that operated Arkansas Nightclubs. It alleges, upon information and belief, that each MLT Defendant, directly or through shared decision makers and affiliated operating entities, purposefully directed continuing management, marketing, and promotional activities into Arkansas, participated in managing the Arkansas Nightclubs and the challenged Arkansas advertising system, and derived commercial benefit from the Nightclubs' Arkansas operations. It pleads venue in the Western District of Arkansas under 28 U.S.C. § 1391(b)(2) because a substantial part of the events and omissions giving rise to the claims occurred in Fort Smith and Fayetteville, Arkansas, and because two of the three Nightclubs are located in this District. It pleads that assignment to the Fort Smith Division is appropriate because Fort Smith is in Sebastian County. It pleads joinder under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 20(a). (Compl. paras. 10-15.)