The complaint

Big Red Plumbing LLC v. Buckaroo Plumbing LLC, No. 2:26-cv-00778 (D. Idaho), is a 17-page complaint filed November 16, 2026, as ECF No. 1, with a demand for a jury trial on all claims and issues so triable. Big Red Plumbing LLC, doing business as Believe Plumbing, is an Idaho limited liability company. The complaint says its principal place of business is in Sandpoint, Idaho, and that it also operates from Hayden, Idaho. It says Believe, formerly known as Big Red Plumbing, provides residential plumbing services throughout North Idaho. The defendants are Buckaroo Plumbing LLC, an Idaho limited liability company, and two individuals, Cole Pulsipher and Marina Pulsipher. The complaint alleges, on information and belief, that Buckaroo does business as Buckaroo Plumbing, that it was formerly known as Method Plumbing, and that its principal place of business is in Post Falls, Idaho. It alleges, on information and belief, that Cole Pulsipher and Marina Pulsipher each reside in Post Falls, Idaho, that each is an owner of Buckaroo, and that they personally selected, approved, and directed the creation and continued use of the accused trade dress. The complaint alleges personal jurisdiction because each defendant resides in and/or is organized under the laws of Idaho, and each committed the alleged tortious acts in Idaho. It alleges that venue is proper under 28 U.S.C. § 1391(b)(1) and (2), and that the Northern Division is the appropriate division because the parties are located in, and the events occurred in, Kootenai and Bonner Counties. It alleges subject-matter jurisdiction over the Lanham Act claims under 15 U.S.C. § 1121 and 28 U.S.C. §§ 1331 and 1338(a), and over the Idaho claim under 28 U.S.C. §§ 1338(b) and 1367(a).

The trade dress

The complaint claims trade dress in the overall look of Believe's service vans. It calls that look the Believe Trade Dress: the combination of a full-vehicle wrap depicting a sunset in a gradient of purple, orange, and yellow, with snowcapped mountains and an evergreen treeline along the lower portion of the side panels; a large, full-body, cartoon-style mascot in an illustrated style, placed on the side panel next to the logo; a logo in which the first word of the company name appears in large, stylized, outlined lettering filled with a yellow gradient from light to dark; the word PLUMBING in a smaller font on a curved banner directly beneath that word; and the company slogan in small, light-colored lettering directly above the logo. The complaint says the claim is in the overall combination and arrangement, and that this combination identifies Believe as the source of its services.

The complaint alleges that Believe owns the trade dress through exclusive use in commerce and, in addition, that a third-party company assigned to Believe all right, title, and interest the company held in the underlying design, effective May 4, 2025. It alleges that the trade dress is non-functional: the elements are ornamental and source-identifying, none is essential to the use or purpose of a plumbing service vehicle or of plumbing services, and none affects their cost or quality. It alleges that the trade dress is inherently distinctive and, in the alternative, that it has acquired distinctiveness. On that alternative, the complaint says Believe's wrapped vans travel throughout North Idaho daily and are parked outside customers' homes during service calls, that Believe features the vans and the brand on its website and on social media accessible nationwide, and that the defendants' imitation is further evidence of distinctiveness. It alleges continuous use in commerce since at least February 2026, before the defendants' first use of the accused wrap.

What the complaint alleges

The complaint alleges that Believe participates in a plumbing-business coaching program. It says the program encourages members to adopt a friendly, distinctive brand and refers them to professional branding firms, and that Believe found the third-party company through that referral. On May 4, 2025, the complaint alleges, Believe engaged that company to develop a new brand identity, including a business name, logo, mascot, color palette, and vehicle wrap, and paid the company in full. In October 2025, Believe filed to do business under the name Believe Plumbing. On December 11, 2025, the complaint alleges, the company published images of the completed van wrap on its Facebook page and other online channels as part of its public portfolio. On February 16, 2026, Believe publicly posted a preview that partially showed its newly wrapped van, put its first wrapped van into service in February 2026, and kept previewing the brand over the following weeks. The complaint alleges that Believe completed its public brand launch on March 18, 2026, put a second wrapped van into service on or about March 22, 2026, and now operates a fleet of vans bearing the wrap. It alleges that Believe invested substantially in the rebrand, including the company's fees and the cost of producing and installing the wraps, which ran several thousand dollars per van. It says Believe promotes the brand through its vehicles, its website CallBelievePlumbing.com, and social media, advertises on platforms accessible nationwide, buys equipment and materials shipped from outside Idaho, and serves customers near the Washington border.

The complaint alleges that Buckaroo is a residential plumbing company in the same North Idaho service area, including Sandpoint, Coeur d'Alene, Hayden, Post Falls, Sagle, and Athol, and that it competes with Believe for the same customers. It alleges that Cole Pulsipher and Marina Pulsipher own Buckaroo, that they are also members of the coaching program, and that they joined the program's online community on or about March 5, 2026. It alleges that as of mid-March 2026 they had not chosen a new name; that on or about March 12, 2026, they sought feedback on the name Buckaroo in a program group session; and that on March 13, 2026, Marina Pulsipher announced the name Buckaroo Plumbing and the defendants filed that day to reserve the name with the Idaho Secretary of State. By then, the complaint alleges, the Believe Trade Dress had been in the third-party company's public portfolio for three months, and Believe's wrapped vans were in service in North Idaho. On April 24, 2026, the complaint alleges, Marina Pulsipher posted an image of Buckaroo's van wrap to the community, described it as an "almost final draft," and said the defendants were "a couple weeks away" from their rebrand.

The complaint alleges that within weeks of Believe's launch the defendants put a van on the road in a wrap that copies the overall look of the Believe Trade Dress, that they operate in the same towns and offer the same services, and that they knew of Believe's design before they finalized their own. It alleges, on information and belief, that by May 2026 the defendants had begun using service vehicles bearing a wrap, and displaying that wrap on BuckarooPlumbing.com. On information and belief, the complaint describes that wrap as a full-vehicle sunset in a gradient of purple, orange, and yellow, with snowcapped mountains along the lower portion of the side panels; a large, full-body, cartoon-style mascot in a similar illustrated style, placed on the side panel next to the logo at a comparable scale; a logo in which BUCKAROO appears in large, stylized, outlined lettering filled with a yellow gradient from light to dark that the complaint calls essentially identical to Believe's; the word PLUMBING in a smaller, nearly identical font on a curved banner directly beneath; and the company slogan in small, light-colored lettering directly above the logo. The complaint alleges that the defendants personally designed or directed that design and, in their own words, designed it "very closely ourselves." It alleges that they use the wrap to advertise and provide residential plumbing services in the same communities, including through BuckarooPlumbing.com displayed on the vehicle, and that Believe never authorized the use.

The complaint alleges that on May 22, 2026, Believe's owner encountered Cole Pulsipher, and that Cole Pulsipher said the defendants had seen Believe's design in the third-party company's portfolio and had been inspired by it. The same day, it alleges, Marina Pulsipher posted in the coaching program's community group on Facebook a photograph of a Buckaroo van parked beside a Believe van, with a caption that, the complaint says, publicly called the two vans "twin[s]." The complaint alleges that the defendants finalized the accused wrap after the Believe Trade Dress was public: they did not choose the name until March 13, 2026, and they had not finalized the wrap as of April 24, 2026. It alleges actual confusion: that several members of the public in Believe's service area told Believe they believed a Buckaroo vehicle was Believe's, and that others approached Believe's personnel about the similarity. It alleges that the owner of a local excavating company that does business with Believe wrote to ask whether the two companies used the same marketing firm, and said she had been "confused for a moment," and that another person affiliated with that company reached out on June 3, 2026, to say that the defendants' wrap looked similar to Believe's vans. In or about June 2026, the complaint alleges, owners of two other local businesses saw a Buckaroo van, contacted Believe to ask whether the companies were related, and said they had been confused.

The complaint alleges that on or about June 22, 2026, Believe wrote to the defendants about the similarity and asked them to change the design. It alleges that they answered in writing, acknowledged the vehicles' "similar color scheme," said they posted the photograph to the coaching group because they "thought it was funny and that great minds think alike," and said the similarities "could be used to our mutual benefit." On July 8, 2026, the complaint alleges, Believe sent a formal written notice of its rights in the trade dress and demanded that the defendants stop using the accused wrap. The same day, it alleges, Marina Pulsipher posted in the same Facebook group and acknowledged the closeness of the two color schemes. The complaint alleges that the defendants denied infringement and continue to use the wrap. It alleges that they have known of the Believe Trade Dress, and of the confusion, since at least May 22, 2026, and have had written notice since at least June 22, 2026, and that the continued use is knowing and willful. It alleges irreparable harm, including loss of control over Believe's reputation, erosion of the source-identifying power of the trade dress, and loss of goodwill, and it alleges that Believe has no adequate remedy at law.

The claims and the prayer

Count I pleads trade dress infringement under 15 U.S.C. § 1125(a). The complaint alleges that the accused wrap creates an overall commercial impression closely similar to the Believe Trade Dress; that the parties offer identical services to the same customers in the same North Idaho communities; that both market through the same channels, including service vehicles, social media, and local community groups; that residential plumbing is bought by ordinary consumers, often urgently and without a high degree of care; that the defendants adopted the wrap with knowledge of Believe's trade dress; that the use has already caused actual confusion; and that the defendants have acknowledged the similarity. It alleges use without Believe's consent, and that Cole Pulsipher and Marina Pulsipher are personally liable because they personally authorized, directed, and participated in the alleged infringement. Count II pleads unfair competition and false designation of origin under 15 U.S.C. § 1125(a)(1)(A). The complaint alleges that the use is a false designation of origin and a false or misleading representation of fact, likely to cause confusion, mistake, or deception as to the defendants' affiliation, connection, or association with Believe and as to the origin, sponsorship, or approval of their services by Believe. It alleges that Believe is their direct competitor, and that the conduct has injured Believe's reputation and sales by diverting customers and goodwill and by depriving Believe of control over the reputation associated with the trade dress. Count III pleads trade dress infringement and unfair competition under Idaho common law. The complaint alleges that Believe's rights in Idaho are protectable, non-functional, and distinctive, and that they predate the defendants' first use. It alleges that the defendants adopted and used the wrap to provide identical services to the same customers in the same market, and that the use passes off their services as Believe's or as affiliated with Believe.

The complaint asks for judgment on all counts. It asks for a preliminary and permanent injunction under 15 U.S.C. § 1116(a) and Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 65 against use of the accused trade dress, or any confusingly similar dress, in advertising, promoting, offering, or providing plumbing or related services. It asks for an order under 15 U.S.C. § 1118 requiring delivery for destruction of vehicle wraps, signs, labels, advertisements, and other materials bearing the accused dress, and of the means of making them. It asks for the defendants' profits attributable to their infringement under 15 U.S.C. § 1117(a), increased in such sum as the court finds just if the recovery based on profits is inadequate; actual damages under § 1117(a), enhanced up to three times the amount found as the court finds just, which the complaint ties to what it calls the willful nature of the defendants' conduct; a finding that the case is exceptional and an award of reasonable attorney's fees under § 1117(a); and costs under § 1117(a), 28 U.S.C. § 1920, and Rule 54(d)(1). It also asks for compensatory damages under Idaho common law, pre-judgment interest as allowed by law, post-judgment interest under 28 U.S.C. § 1961, and other and further relief, in law or in equity, to which the plaintiff may be entitled or which the court deems just and proper.

What to watch next

On November 16, 2026, the day it filed the complaint, the plaintiff moved for a preliminary injunction (ECF No. 3), and the docket shows two supporting affidavits with exhibits (ECF Nos. 4 and 5). The docket sets responses due by December 7, 2026. Watch for a response to that motion and a ruling on it, and for an answer or a Rule 12 motion. The case can end at any time, including by settlement or voluntary dismissal.